It’s no secret that we have quite a long list of favorite foods you’ll find around Disney World. Corn dog nuggets from Casey’s Corner? Check. Cheeseburger Pods from Satu’li Canteen? Check. But, just because we have our top eats doesn’t mean we’re not always looking for MORE snacks to add to our favorites list.
The Cake Bake Shop
We heard there were some new treats available at The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers, so you know we had to RUN to go check it out. How does it compare to the other sweet treats we’ve tried from this bakery? Let’s dig in and find out!
The first new treat that we tried has arrived just in time for Valentine’s Day. It’s the Amour de Macaron for $14.99. Yes, before you ask, it’s shaped like a heart. ?This tasted like the Marie Antoinette version we previously had here, which had a sort of rose macaron thing going on. However, the heart shape makes it a little more fun.
Amour de Macaron
However, we did get more of the lemon curd in it and it seems like the heart shape makes it a bit more crumbly. The raspberries and raspberry jam just pulls it all together, flavor-wise. It’s a nice Valentine’s Day treat.
SO good
We also tried the Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse Pie for $16.99. Our reporter described this as a Reese’s Pieces cup in mousse pie form. It also melts REALLY fast in the heat. It’s very rich, and the chocolate on the outside is nice and thick. The peanut butter mousse is like whipped peanut butter, and all the flavors just come together.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse Pie
The crust was like a chocolate Oreo crumble. Basically, if you love Reese’s, GET THIS PIE. Our only thing is that we don’t feel the size necessarily justifies $17.
A Reese’s lover dream
Finally, we HAD to get a slice of the Coconut Cake, which is a seasonal offering. It’s $22.99 for a slice. We did notice that it didn’t hold together as well as some of the other cake slices here, but that’s a minor complaint. The vanilla cake is interwoven with layers of icing and coconut shavings, and it’s just DECADENT in all the right ways.
Coconut Cake
The cake is moist, too. We will say that this isn’t our FAVORITE slice here, but we think coconut cake fans are going to love it.
It’s moist and crumbly
So that’s our review of the latest sweet treats at The Cake Bake Shop. We’ll be on the lookout for the latest eats throughout Disney World, so don’t forget to stay tuned to the Disney Food Blog so you don’t miss any reviews and other Disney news.
See ALL of our Cake Bake Shop reviews here!
Need Disney Restaurant Advice? We’ve Got EVERYTHING You Need to Know
The ONLY Disney Dining Planning Tool You’ll Need Is Here – Get the DFB Guide to Walt Disney World Dining!
See Our Complete Disney World Restaurants Guide
The Best Magic Kingdom Restaurants
The Best EPCOT Restaurant Restaurants
The Best Hollywood Studios Restaurants
The Best Animal Kingdom Restaurants
The Best Disney Springs Restaurants
Check Out Dozens of Disney Dining Tips and Tools
Learn All About Tipping at Disney Restaurants
How to Use Mobile Order in Disney World
Join the DFB Newsletter to get all the latest Disney food news right in your inbox! Click here to Subscribe!
Will you be grabbing this new slice from the Cake Bake Shop? Tell us in the comments.
Our handy (and portable!) ebook guides make sure you get the best deals and can plan a vacation of a lifetime.
Definitely when we arrive in sept , that peanut butter slice looks ?, been meaning to visit, we are from the land of cake and tea after all , the good ole UK , yes it’s pricey, but you can share , so its not so bad , and it’s a real treat . I hope it’s a success . Defo belongs alone the boardwalk
Not a chance, not a cake in the world worth $23.00 a slice even with cost of eggs. Another example of price gouging in WDW.
Thanks for letting us know the prices of the PIECE of cake. We had want to go but not now. Talk about over pricing . No piece of cake is worth those prices. Even with the price increase of the ingredient no piece of cake is worth those prices.